Here is a puzzle. A personal injury case settles. The other side's insurer pays. The check clears the firm's trust account. And the client, the person the whole thing was for, waits another few months for their money.
Ask around and you'll hear the usual suspects: the insurer is slow, the lawyer is busy, the paperwork is a mess. But follow the money for one settlement and something stranger shows up. Almost everyone in the chain is behaving rationally. The delay is what you get when a dozen reasonable decisions are stacked on top of each other.
One of our founders lived this. A rear-end collision, the other driver found 100% at fault, an open-and-shut case. The settlement check still took about a year to reach her. What held it up wasn't the case. It was the liens.
Meet the people waiting for the same dollar
A settlement isn't one payment. It's a pile of money with several claims on it: the client, the firm's fee, case costs, and lienholders such as health plans, hospitals and, very often, Medicare. Each of those parties wants to be paid from the same pile, and some of them don't know their final number yet.
Medicare is the clearest example. Early in a case, Medicare sends a conditional payment letter listing what it has paid for the injury so far. It's tempting to treat that figure as the bill. It isn't. Medicare's actual recovery is set in a final demand, issued after the settlement is reported and reduced for the fees and costs of getting the settlement. Once the final demand is issued, it is due within 60 days, and interest runs from the date of the letter if it isn't paid on time. (Our guide walks through the whole process.)
The rules tell the firm to pay promptly. The math tells the firm to wait. Both are right.
The incentive nobody talks about
Now put yourself in the firm's chair. If you pay the client against the conditional figure and the final demand comes back higher, the firm is short, and a shortfall in a trust account is exactly the kind of thing that ends up in front of the bar. If you hold everything until every lien is final, nobody can accuse you of under-reserving. So holding feels safe.
But holding has its own rule. ABA Model Rule 1.15 requires lawyers to deliver promptly the funds a client or third party is entitled to receive. California makes the clock explicit: absent good cause, it presumes a violation if undisputed funds aren't distributed within 45 days of becoming undisputed, and it requires notice within 14 days of receiving the funds. When only part of the money is in dispute, only that part is supposed to stay in trust.
So the honest answer to "who's holding up the check?" is often: a careful firm, protecting itself from one rule and drifting toward another.
Why the waiting compounds
Each lien is its own small negotiation: request the itemization, dispute what isn't related to the injury, wait for a revised figure, repeat. When those negotiations are tracked in email threads and a spreadsheet someone updates on Fridays, the whole settlement moves at the speed of the slowest lien. One stubborn hospital bill can hold up money that has nothing to do with it.
What fast firms do differently
The firms that disburse quickly don't take more risk. They split the problem. They find liens when the case opens instead of when it settles. They track each lien as its own line with its own status and its own clock. And they separate the money into two piles the day it arrives: what's disputed, which stays in trust, and what isn't, which goes out.
That's also the kind of work software is good at. suss. surfaces liens when a matter opens, keeps every client ledger reconciled daily, and shows which part of a settlement is still waiting on a final number, so the rest can be approved and paid. A person at the firm approves anything that moves money.
What to do Monday
- Pull every matter where settlement funds have been in trust for more than 30 days and list what each one is waiting on.
- For each, split the balance into disputed and undisputed. Anything undisputed should have a payment date.
- Start a lien log for new matters at intake: lienholder, amount claimed, status, date of last contact.
- Check your state's rule on prompt delivery and notice. Find it here.
Common questions
Why does it take so long to get a personal injury settlement check?
Usually because of liens. Health plans, hospitals and Medicare may all have a claim on the settlement, and their final amounts often aren't known when the settlement clears. Firms hold funds until those figures are final, which can take months if each lien is negotiated one at a time.
Is a Medicare conditional payment letter the final amount owed?
No. It lists what Medicare has paid so far. Medicare's recovery is set in the final demand, which is issued after the settlement is reported and is reduced for the fees and costs of obtaining the settlement. The final demand is due within 60 days, with interest if it's late.
Can a firm hold all settlement money until every lien is resolved?
Rules generally require prompt delivery of funds a client is entitled to, and only the disputed portion should stay in trust. California, for example, presumes a violation if undisputed funds aren't distributed within 45 days absent good cause. Check your state's rule.
Know where every dollar is, every morning.
suss. reconciles bank, book and every client ledger daily, flags exceptions the day they happen, and keeps the record your bar asks for. A person at your firm approves anything that moves money.
Schedule a demoSources and rules cited (5)
General information, not legal or tax advice. Rules vary by state and change; check your state bar's current rules.